What are the 5 Tiers of Storage for New Video Production Workflows?

What are the characteristics of each storage tier and when should you use NVMe, SAN, NAS, Cloud, Object, or Tape Storage?

 


As your digital video workflows grow in scope, your underlying storage strategy must adapt. The days of buying one tier of storage for editing and one tier for archive are quickly coming to an end due to rapidly evolving asset reuse, globally distributed workflows and on-demand delivery requirements.

Topic Overview:

So, how do you define your storage strategy to create better, more cost-effective workflows? What are the characteristics of each tier of storage needed? And, what are the variables to consider when defining how much of a specific storage tier you need?


video-content-challenges-file-size-creation-consumption-protection-access

What are Some Challenges of Video Content?

Increasing File Sizes

1080P workflows are quickly turning into 4K workflows with 8K workflows starting to take hold and 16K cameras looming on the horizon. Therefore, both the size of the image (the resolution) and the size of the resulting files are growing. In addition, uncompressed workflows are now being requested, resulting in multi-TB sized files.

Aspects of Creation & Consumption

The rise of video on-demand (VOD) services, broadband and mobile devices have changed the way content is produced and consumed in several ways, including:

  • Consumers now view content when they have time, on the device that’s most convenient to them
  • Resolutions range from mobile (720, 1080, 2K) to 4K with 8K TVs hitting the market
  • You now have to create various versions, dimensions, resolutions for the exact same piece of content

Protection & Access

With video being repurposed and reused, nothing is thrown away, and the need to protect content and keep it accessible is critical. Here are some of the factors that intensify the need for protection and access:

  • Video content has intrinsic value well beyond the initial use
  • All project files, source footage and produced content need to remain instantly accessible
  • On-demand workflows are straining workflows based on tape, it takes too long to recall assets

digital-storage-requirements-speed-length-repurpose-archive

What are the Requirements for Video Storage?

  1. Speed: What is the speed required to perform your particular task? If you are editing 8K footage in an uncompressed format, you are going to need really fast storage. If you need playout functionality playing back compressed formats over the web, you don’t need as much speed. The goal is to match the speed to the task.
  2. Length of File Use: How long are files going to be used for their immediate purpose? How long do they have to stay on a particular tier of storage?
  3. Repurposing: When is a specific file going to be reused? Is it within 6 months?
  4. Archiving: If you know if and when a file will be repurposed, you can develop your archive strategy. For instance, if you are not going to use a file within 6 months, perhaps it’s time to move that file to a secondary or tertiary tier of storage.

Once we look at our workflows and file use characteristics through the lens of these requirements, we can start to determine what capacities we need for each specific tier of storage to complete our task. Now let’s take a look at the 5 tiers of storage available for new video workflows.


What are the 5 Tiers of Video Data Storage?

Storage Tiers:

  1. Ultra-Fast NVMe
  2. Fast SAN/NAS
  3. NAS & Filer
  4. Local Archive
  5. Cloud Archive

storage-tier-nvme-pros-cons

Ultra-Fast NVMe

Ultra fast NVMe is similar to RAM. This is the type of storage needed for 8K or 16K uncompressed workflows since it is faster than SSDs. You can get content off the drive quickly due to low latency and do it with less drives than used in a traditional RAID array. However, networking requirements are massive, along with the resulting compute and overall price tag. This isn’t a cheap solution which is why you buy the amount needed for your specific task.


storage-tier-ultra-fast-nas-san-pros-cons

Ultra-Fast SAN/NAS Architecture

This is your more traditional SAN and NAS environment needed for high-speed editing platforms. They are fast and reliable and optimized for video workflows with large capacity drives and arrays with a multitude of connectivity options (10 Gig, 40 Gig, Fibre…). However, networking upgrades may be required. There are high costs of ownership due to power/maintenance, and performance degrades as they near capacity. These factors are behind the need to eventually offload files to different tiers of storage.


storage-tier-nas-filer-pros-cons

NAS & Filer

If your content has a shelf life of 3–6 months then you may want to consider putting it on a NAS or filer. They are relatively low cost (vs NVMe and Ultrafast NAS/SAN) with Petabyte-level capacity. However, they have limited scalability beyond multiple Petabytes, are often not accessible over the web, and have long rebuild times in the case of a sector or drive failure. In addition, support and maintenance fees in subsequent years can often exceed the original purchase price.


storage-tier-local-archive-lto-object-storage-pros-cons

Local Archival

For on-prem and local archive, you have two options. LTO (tape) or Object Storage (HDD based). The benefits of LTO are low cost per TB with virtually unlimited tape capacities. However, you are locked into a tape format, maintenance is often an issue, and if the files are stored across tape drives it can take a long time to recall assets. The benefits of object storage are also the low cost per TB with a cloud-like low maintenance experience and dense capacities. However, object-based storage requires available data center footprint and (like LTO) an HSM or data mover to plug into certain file-system-based workflows. For most organizations, dealing with new video production workflows and on-demand requirements, object storage is the tier of storage with the most rapid rate of growth.


storage-tier-cloud-archive-pros-cons

Cloud Archival

The cloud also employs both LTO and object storage technologies to enable archive services. The benefits include zero maintenance with unlimited capacity and instant deployment. The benefits, however, come at a cost that compounds over time and is always more expensive than on-prem solutions if you are keeping assets for more than 2–3 years.


mapping-storage-requirements-nvme-nas-san-filer-archive-cloud-archive

Which Storage Tier is Best for My Requirements?

Depending on your requirements, you can match the appropriate type of storage. This is illustrated in the chart above. The circles in the chart above represent the amount of time that files are going to sit on each tier of storage, based upon the requirement. For instance, if speed is the primary requirement then files will sit on NVMe or Ultra-Fast NAS/SAN. However, if archive is the primary requirement, the file will most likely be on your local archive or cloud archive tier. This table is another tool you can use to help you map your current workflows to the associated tier of storage.


mapping-storage-workflows-nvme-nas-san-archive-cloud-archive

Which Storage Workflow is Best for Video Production?

Similar to the previous matrix, the table above shows what storage tier is ideal for a specific workflow. For instance, for production you would most often use NVMe or Fast NAS/SAN. For video-on-demand (VOD) or over-the-top (OTT) enablement, you would most often use a local archive or the cloud. You can also use NAS for VOD and OTT; however, you would need to add additional layers of infrastructure like a web server. For archiving projects or masters, a local archive or the cloud are the clear choices.


storage-streamlines-workflows-video on demand and over the top

Learn How Storage Can Streamline VOD & OTT Workflows

Watch this on-demand webinar to learn how storage streamlines workflows in the VOD/OTT era. You will see how you can stream content directly from storage, how to set up multi-site content distribution for collaboration, and how to unify file systems like NFS and RESTful S3 workloads. In addition, you will gain an understanding of the pros and cons of using object storage vs tape storage.


Conclusion

We hope that the information covered in this blog and the different tools presented help you define your storage strategy. As always, we and our partners at JB&A Distribution are here to help. If you have questions or would like to schedule a custom demo, contact us today.

The number of tiers of storage you deploy and their resulting capacity is all going to come down to your budget and the requirements determined by a needs analysis. If you are struggling with editing 8K or 16K uncompressed files, then you should take a look at NVMe. On the other hand, if you are struggling with VOD/OTT enablement or keeping archives instantly accessible, you should take a look at object storage or the cloud.

Adrian Herrera
Adrian Herrera

About The Author

Adrian "AJ" Herrera has over 20 years of experience bringing innovative storage, cloud and media software and services to market. With an MBA from San Diego State University and a BS in Information Systems from Chapman University, AJ serves as Caringo's VP of Marketing.


More From Author